# ICSE X Standard Marks Criteria

As a result of the ongoing pandemic and the changing nature of covid 19 cases in India, the CISCE have decided to cancel Class Xth and XIIth year 2021 exams. The cancellation of the examinations by the CISCE was done keeping in mind the safety, health & wellbeing of the students. The main challenge before the CISCE was to provide certification & results to students registered and confirmed to take the ICSE / ISC year 2021 examinations, without having the written examinations. However the CISCE is committed on devising a fair and unbiased criterion for the preparation of result.

**The Parameters / Data from schools
**The CISCE have decided upon the following broad parameters which would be used for the computations of the marks. The CISCE has requisitioned the submission of the necessary data by the schools concerned vide its circulars dated 29

^{th}April 2021 & 27

^{th}May 2021, for the ICSE examination & the ISC examination, respectively:

ICSE Class Xth

ICSE Class Xth

The Average marks of papers / subjects scored by students in various tests / examinations conducted by the school at the classes IX and X through the academic years 2019-20 & 2020-21 respectively (in percentage form, i.e. out of 100) Internal assessment of marks (the project work and practical for the ICSE year 2021 examination).

The data submitted by the schools was analysed by a team of reputed Statisticians from some of the Premier institutions in the country, along with Senior Officials of the CISCE. An extensive scenario analysis was done based on the data gathered for different subjects. Most importantly while devising the methodology for computing marks, the endeavor was also to ensure fairness to all students confirmed to appear for the ICSE / ISC year 2021 examinations to the best possible content.

After the detailed analysis of the data, methodology was decided upon, for the computation of marks for each student, for each subject / paper.

__Methodology of Computation of Results
__ICSE (Class X)

**Factors used in the computation**

1. Best Year for school:From among the overall result of a school in the ICSE Years 2015 to 2020 Examinations, restricted only to those years when at least 10 candidates appeared for the ICSE Examination in English and at least four other subjects from the school, the best year for this school will be the year when the school achieved the best average percentage (%) in terms of the total scores (out of 500 i.e., English + best 4 subjects).

1. Best Year for school:

**2. Benchmark Standard Deviation (common for all subjects) for a school (o): ** It is the Standard Deviation of the percentage (%) marks based on English + best four subjects (out of 500) obtained by all candidates of that school who appeared in the Best Year (as per #1).

**EXCEPTION:** The value of o for a school that never had at least 10 candidates appearing for English and at least four other subjects in a single year, will be the National Standard Deviation of the total scores for the previous ICSE Examination (Year 2020) conducted by the CISCE.

3. **Subject benchmark average percentage for a school (u):** It is the school average percentage (%), in the theory paper of a subject in the Best Year for the School (as per #1), provided at least 10 candidates appeared for the subject from the school that year.

**EXCEPTION:** If a school did not have at least 10 candidates appearing for the ICSE Examination for a particular subject, in the Best Year for the School (as per #1), the National Average Percentage(%) of the subject from the previous ICSE Examination (Year 2020) conducted by the CISCE [calculated using the theory percentage (%) of the subject of all candidates appearing for that subject in the Year 2020 Examination], will be used as the subject benchmark average u for that subject for that school. For subjects newly introduced for the ICSE Year 2021 Examination, the value of u will be taken to be equal to m as to be computed in #10.

4. **Subject raw theory percentage (Praw):** The maximum of the average percentage (%) marks obtained by a candidate in the theory paper of the said subject, in either Class IX or Class X.

5. **Subject Project and/or Practical Work Marks (PS):** Total marks obtained by the candidate in the Project and/or Practical Work of the subject.

6. **Percentage Subject Project and/or Practical work (B):** Percentage (%) of marks obtained by the candidate in the Project and/or Practical Work of the subject. Note that it is the marks obtained for a Project and/or Practical Work, expressed as a percentage (%).

7. **Subject Raw Marks:** P raw weightage for board (theory) marks + PS (from #4 and #5) for subjects with Project and/or Practical Work components.

Note: Weightage for board (theory) marks is =

__maximum (theory) marks of a subject
__ 100

**EXCEPTION:** For subjects with no Project and/or Practical Work components, the subject raw marks is taken as equal to Praw.

8. **Raw total:** Using the Subject Raw Marks (from #7) the Total Marks (out of 500) for a candidate for English and best four subjects will be calculated.

9. **Raw Standard Deviation (common for all subjects) for a school (s):** It is the Standard Deviation of the percentage based on the raw totals (out of 500) obtained by all candidates of the school appearing for English and at least four other subjects in ICSE Year 2021 Examination (see #8).

**EXCEPTION:** If a school has less than 10 candidates appearing for English and at least four other subjects in ICSE Year 2021 Examination, the National Standard Deviation of the Raw Totals from ICSE Year 2021 Examination (for candidates appearing for English and at least four other subjects) will be the value of s for that school.

10. **Subject Raw Average Percentage for a School (m):** It is the school average percentage in the theory paper for the subject in ICSE Year 2021 Examination, provided at least 10 candidates appeared for the subject from that school in the ICSE Year 2021 Examination.

**EXCEPTION:** If a school does not have at least 10 candidates appearing for a subject in ICSE Year 2021 Examination, the National Raw Theory Percentage average for the ICSE Year 2021 Examination (calculated using raw theory percentages of the subject of all candidates appearing for that subject in ICSE Year 2021 Examination) will be used as the Subject Raw Average Percentage m for that subject, for that school.

**ALGORITHM TO BE USED:
**(a) Compute the scaled score (A) as: A=

__ơ__(P

_{raw}– m) + µ

__s__

__ơ__(Point #2), s (Point #9), P

_{raw}(Point #4), m (Point #10), µ (Point #3)] Note: For the above calculation, if

__ơ__> 4 replace it by 4.

s,

If the obtained value of A> 100, take A = 100.

If the obtained value of A<10, take A = 10.

(b) Obtain the Subject Board (theory) Marks Percentage (percentage of marks obtained by the algorithm which will be awarded to the candidate for the board examination in a subject, in the theory paper) by:

**SUBJECT BOARD (THEORY) MARKS PERCENTAGE = 0.7 A +0.3 B**

Where the weightage of A is 70% and B is 30%

Where:

– Scaled Score** (A): **A= __ơ __ (P_{raw} – m) + µ __
__ s

**
– **Percentage Subject Project and/or Practical Work (B)

**Note:**For subjects without a project and / or practical component, the subject board (theory) marks percentage will be taken to be equal to A. The same formula will be used for candidates who were unable to appear in the practical examinations.

(c) Determine the Subject Board (theory) Marks as:

**SUBJECT BOARD (THEORY) MARKS = SUBJECT BOARD (THEORY) MARKS PERCENTAGE X WEIGHTAGE FOR BOARD (THEORY) MARKS
**

(d) Obtain the Subject Final Marks as:

**SUBJECT FINAL MARKS = SUBJECT BOARD (THEORY) MARKS + SUBJECT**

**PROJECT and/or PRACTICAL WORK MARKS**

For subjects without project/practical work component, take the Subject Final Marks to be the same as the Subject Board Marks.

RATIONALE:

1. The components used to arrive at the formula to award the marks in the subjects which have Project and/or Practical Work component are limited to:

– Marks obtained for the Project and/or Practical Work in the subjects for the ICSE Year 2021 Examination.

– The performance of the candidates in the school examinations in each of the subjects in either Class IX or Class X, measured through their maximum percentage marks obtained in the theory paper of the two years (referred to henceforth as raw marks)

– The best performance of the school in the Board Examinations in the last six years (ICSE Years 2015 to 2020 Examinations).

The first two factors measure the subject proficiency of the candidates, while the last is a measure of the general quality of the schools the candidates are appearing from.

2. The theory marks awarded to the candidates are taken as a weighted average of their project and practical work component, and the base and scale adjusted raw marks. To arrive at the weights, detailed analyses were performed on the data from the past ICSE Board Examinations from the Years 2015 to 2020. Extensive scenario analyses were done based on different subjects. Most importantly, the weights were so chosen as to ensure fairness to all the candidates appearing in the Board

Examination this year, to the best possible extent.

3. For schools / subjects with very few candidates, reliable benchmarking based on past/present data of the school is not possible. For such situations, the benchmarking will be done using the appropriate national benchmarks.

**ILLUSTRATION: **

**(For a subject with 20% marks allocated for Internal Assessment marks and 80% for Theory marks, the subject MATHEMATICS is taken as an example.)
**Assume that the school from which the candidate in this example is appearing, had at least 10 or more ICSE candidates appearing for English, and at least four other subjects every year, during ICSE Years 2015 to 2020 Examinations, and the same is the case in ICSE Year 2021 Examination. Also, assume that there are 10 or more candidates appearing for MATHEMATICS in ICSE Year 2021 Examination from the School.

Suppose the school achieved the highest school average in ICSE Year 2019 Examination. Then for that school, the best year is 2019, which will be used in all our subsequent calculations.

Suppose in the Year 2019, the Standard Deviation of the percentage based on the total scores (out of 500) obtained by all candidates of the school appearing for English and at least four other subjects was 9. Hence, for the school, benchmark standard deviation (o) will be 9 (Refer to IV ICSE subpart 2).

Now, suppose we observe that the average percentage marks that the students obtained in MATHEMATICS theory from the school in Year 2019 was 70. Then Benchmark Average Percentage (u) for MATHEMATICS will be u = 70 (Refer to IV ICSE subpart 3).

Assume that the candidate concerned has obtained 90% Average Marks in Class IX, and 80% Average Marks in Class X in MATHEMATICS theory. Then the candidate’s raw percentage of MATHEMATICS theory paper will be considered as 90 (Refer to IV ICSE subpart 4).

Suppose the candidate has obtained 20 (out of 20) in the MATHEMATICS project. Hence the percentage marks in MATHEMATICS project is 100 (B) (Refer to IV ICSE subpart 6).

The raw marks in MATHEMATICS is 90 x 80/100 + 20 = 92.

We compute the Raw Total of this candidate considering his/her raw marks in English and the best four of the other subjects. Next, we do the same for all other candidates from the school.

Suppose the Standard Deviation of these raw marks is 12 (s) (Refer to IV ICSE subpart 9).

Further, suppose the average raw MATHEMATICS theory percentage be 78 for all candidates from the school (m) (Refer to IV ICSE subpart 10).

Hence the scaled score of the candidate in MATHEMATICS will be calculated as per:

**(A) : **__ơ __ (P_{raw} – m) + µ __
__ s

i.e. A: 9/12 (90-78) + 70 = 79

Hence,

**Subject Board (Theory) Marks Percentage = 0.7A + 0.3 B**

Subject (MATHEMATICS) Board (theory) Marks percentage = 0.7 x 79 +0.3 x 100 = 85.3.

**Subject Board (Theory) Marks = Subject Board (theory) Marks Percentage x Weightage for Board (Theory) Marks**

Subject (MATHEMATICS) Board (Theory) Marks = 85.3 x 0.8 = 68.24 -68

Subject Final Marks = Subject Board (Theory) Marks + Subject Project and/or **Practical Work Marks
**Subject (MATHEMATICS) Final Total Marks = 68 + 20 = 88.

**1.** **PREPARATION OF RESULTS
**1. After obtaining the marks for each candidate, for each subject / paper, using the above methodology, the CISCE will prepare the results of the ICSE and ISC Year 2021 Examinations, incorporating the same processes, as has been the practice in the previous years

**VI. CANDIDATES WITH SPECIAL DIFFICULTIES
**Consideration will be given to the candidates with Special Difficulty by the committee, as has been the practice in the past, while processing the final results. This will be applicable only to those cases that have been approved by the CISCE for ICSE / ISC Year

**VII. RETENTION OF NECESSARY RECORDS BY SCHOOLS
**All the schools are required to mandatorily retain the Academic Records and the Attendance Records of the candidates for Classes IX & X/XI & XII, as applicable, who were confirmed for ICSE / ISC Year 2021 Examinations. These records will be required by the CISCE for verification and dispute resolution, if any.

**VIII. DECLARATION OF RESULTS
**The CISCE will endeavour to publish the results as expeditiously as possible. Subject to the situation remaining conducive and stable, the results will be published on or before 31st July 2021.

**IX. DISPUTE RESOLUTION MECHANISM FOR CANDIDATES
**(a) In the event a candidate has objection(s) regarding computation of marks in the result, she/he may make a written application to the school concerned, stating the objection in detail along with reasons thereof.

(b) The Head of the School concerned will review the application, and only upon being satisfied with the contentions made therein, forward the same to the CISCE along with her/his comments/remarks endorsing the contentions made and documents supporting the opinion regarding the computation of marks. No application will be entertained by the CISCE unless it is forwarded by the Head of the School concerned. Further, the application must be sent by the Head of the School to the CISCE within 07 days of declaration of results. Applications sent after the expiry of 07 days from the day of declaration of results will not be entertained.

(c) The CISCE will then review the application, the supporting documents and the Head of School’s comments/remarks and convey its decision to the concerned School, in writing. In case the result needs to be altered, the CISCE will notify the Head of the School concerned.

(d) The CISCE will appropriately appoint an inhouse committee for the dispute resolution mechanism. It is made clear for the avoidance of doubt that the Recheck of Answer Scripts is not applicable for the ICSE/ISC Year 2021 Examinations. This dispute resolution mechanism is only for the correction of calculation errors.

**X. IMPROVEMENT EXAMINATION
**Candidates who are not satisfied with the aforesaid assessment scheme will have the option to appear in the written examination in one or more subject(s)/paper(s) which shall be conducted by the CISCE subsequently.

The CISCE will endeavour to hold the improvement examinations as expeditiously as possible after the declaration of the results. Subject to the situation remaining conducive and stable and declaration of results in a timely fashion, the improvement examinations should commence before 1 September 2021. The CISCE will publish the detailed schedule of the improvement examinations well in advance from the commencement of the improvement examination such as to provide adequate opportunity to the students to prepare for the examinations.

The marks scored by the candidates in the improvement examination will be considered.

**XI. COMPARTMENTAL EXAMINATION
ICSE (Class X)
**Candidates who have failed to secure a Pass Certificate and have been awarded a PCNA (Pass Certificate Not Awarded) in the current year of the ICSE Examination, provided they have passed in English and THREE other subjects, will be permitted to appear for the Compartmental Examination in any ONE of the Subject/Paper in which the candidate has not obtained a Pass Grade.

The CISCE will endeavour to hold the Compartmental Examinations as expeditiously as possible after the declaration of the results. Subject to the situation remaining conducive and stable and declaration of results in a timely fashion, the Compartmental Examinations should commence before 1 September 2021. The CISCE will publish the detailed schedule of the Compartmental Examinations later, but in advance of the date of commencement of examination such as to provide adequate opportunity to the students to prepare for the examinations.

**Note: The timelines mentioned in this scheme are tentative and subject to change on account of change in circumstances.
**As held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in its order dated 17.6.2021 in the matter of Mamta Sharma v. CBSE & Ors. [Writ Petition (Civil) No. 522 of 2021], this scheme is subject to further orders of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the said matter.

**JUNE 20, 2021**